|
| C. W. Porter | 1869 |
| C. W. Porter | 1870 |
| W. T. Haynes | 1871 |
| A. A. Rice | 1872 |
| C. W. Porter | 1873 |
| C.W. Porter | 1874 |
| C. W. Porter | 1875 |
| S. P. Latane | 1876 |
| John Bagby | 1877 |
| John Bagby | 1878 |
| C. W. Porter | 1879 |
| No Elections | 1880 |
| P. K. Bauman | 1881 |
| P. K. Bauman | 1882 |
| P.K. Bauman | 1883 |
| S. R. Boughton | 1884 |
| S. R. Boughton | 1885 |
| S. R. Boughton | 1886 |
| C. W. Porter | 1887 |
| C. W. Porter | 1888 |
| P. K. Bauman | 1889 |
| P. K. Bauman | 1890 |
| P. K. Bauman | 1891 |
| P. K. Bauman | 1892 |
| W. F. Bagby | 1893 |
| W. E. Bagby | 1894 |
| C. R. Bray | 1895 |
| C. R. Bray | 1896 |
| J. W. Fleet | 1897 |
| W. D. Hoskins | 1898 |
| W. D. Hoskins | 1899 |
| Theodore Courtney | 1900 |
| J. M. Lewis | 1901 |
| J. L. Henley | 1902 |
| J. L. Henley | 1903 |
| J. L. Henley | 1904 |
| C. B. Hudley | 1905 |
| W. F. Bagby | 1906 |
| E. L. W. Ferry | 1907 |
| E. L. W. Ferry | 1908 |
| W. G. Rennolds | 1909 |
| P. W. Lewis | 1910 |
| P.W. Lewis | 1911 |
| T. B. Latane | 1912 |
| William F. Bagby | 1913 |
| William F. Bagby | 1914 |
| William F. Bagby | 1915 |
| W. G. Rennolds | 1916 |
| C. R. Bray | 1917 |
| J. S. Phillips | 1918 |
| J. S. Phillips | 1919 |
| J. M. Lewis | 1920 |
| F. W. Stiff | 1921 |
| F. W. Stiff | 1922 |
| F. W. Stiff | 1923 |
| W. P. DeShazo | 1924 |
| W. P. DeShazo | 1925 |
| C. A. Gresham | 1926 |
| William F. Bagby | 1927 |
| William F. Bagby | 1928 |
| E. L. W. Ferry | 1929 |
| G. Harold Burrough | 1930 |
| Thomas F. Jones | 1931 |
| Ivan Clark | 1932 |
| W. P. Morris | 1933 |
| H. P. Taylor, Jr. | 1934 |
| H. P. Taylor, Jr. | 1935 |
| J. M. Lewis | 1936 |
| J. L. Parker | 1937 |
| C. A. Warner | 1938 |
| H. S. Atkinson | 1939 |
| F. L. Garrett, Jr. | 1940 |
| John F. Haile | 1941 |
| Gordon Lewis | 1942 |
| Roland S. Sheppard | 1943 |
| A. J. Andrews | 1944 |
| A. J. Andrews | 1945 |
| J. J. Johnson | 1946 |
| P. P. Derieux | 1947 |
| J. L. A. Motley | 1948 |
| E. W. Haile | 1949 |
| Robert L. Hammond | 1950 |
| E. Garrett New | 1951 |
| William B. Watson | 1952 |
| John C. DeShazo, Sr. | 1953 |
| Lawrence C. Brooks | 1954 |
| Ernest C. Vaughan | 1955 |
| Melvin F. Selden | 1956 |
| Carroll P. Barton, PDDGM | 1957 |
| Malcomb P. Ball | 1958 |
| Robert W. Coleman | 1959 |
| Harold A. Little | 1960 |
| Henry N. Ware | 1961 |
| Charles N. DeShazo | 1962 |
| Lawrence C. Brooks | 1963 |
| Marshall W. Haney | 1964 |
| Eugene E. Musselman, Jr. | 1965 |
| Joseph E. Spruill | 1966 |
| Romeo H. Burton, Jr. | 1967 |
| George W. Bussells, Jr. | 1968 |
| John C. DeShazo | 1969 |
| Melvin S. Seay | 1970 |
| Early Lankford, Jr. | 1971 |
| Edward H. Parrish | 1972 |
| William Sylva | 1973 |
| Gene S. McMahan | 1974 |
| Robert L. Moran | 1975 |
| Hugh P. Young, PDDGM | 1976 |
| Robert H. Ball | 1977 |
| Edwin G. Ball | 1978 |
| Walter W. Overstreet | 1979 |
| Clifton T. Davis | 1980 |
| R. Lankford | 1981 |
| Bobby L. Wharton | 1982 |
| Marshall L. Haney | 1983 |
| Seth W. Gayle | 1984 |
| Robert H. Shackelford, Jr. | 1985 |
| William L. Clark | 1986 |
| Walter L. Jackson, PDDGM | 1987 |
| John D. Longest | 1988 |
| Raymond L. Atkins | 1989 |
| Upton D. Ellett | 1990 |
| Carroll P. Barton | 1991 |
| Charles R. Lankford | 1992 |
| Nathan P. Ball | 1993 |
| William T. Passagaluppi | 1994 |
| Norman P. Stinchcomb | 1995 |
| Preston D. Carter | 1996 |
| Linwood E. Wadsworth | 1997 |
| James E. Kickler | 1998 |
| Albert C. Mittelstadter, Jr. | 1999 |
| Early R. Langford, Jr. | 2000 |
| Clifton T. Davis | 2001 |
| James W. Sydnor | 2002 |
| Allen R. Massie | 2003 |
| Robert H. Shackelford, Jr. | 2004 |
| Arthur R. Riles | 2005 |
| William W. Perry | 2006 |
| James Carroll Brown | 2007 |